Hypoxic culture of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stromal stem cells differentially enhances in vitro chondrogenesis within cell-seeded collagen and hyaluronic acid porous scaffolds
© Bornes et al.; licensee BioMed Central. 2015
Received: 5 December 2014
Accepted: 10 April 2015
Published: 23 April 2015
The quality of cartilaginous tissue derived from bone marrow mesenchymal stromal stem cell (BMSC) transplantation has been correlated with clinical outcome. Therefore, culture conditions capable of modulating tissue phenotype, such as oxygen tension and scaffold composition, are under investigation. The objective of this study was to assess the effect of hypoxia on in vitro BMSC chondrogenesis within clinically approved porous scaffolds composed of collagen and hyaluronic acid (HA). It was hypothesized that hypoxic isolation/expansion and differentiation would improve BMSC chondrogenesis in each construct.
Ovine BMSCs were isolated and expanded to passage 2 under hypoxia (3% oxygen) or normoxia (21% oxygen). Cell proliferation and colony-forming characteristics were assessed. BMSCs were seeded at 10 million cells per cubic centimeter on cylindrical scaffolds composed of either collagen I sponge or esterified HA non-woven mesh. Chondrogenic differentiation was performed in a defined medium under hypoxia or normoxia for 14 days. Cultured constructs were assessed for gene expression, proteoglycan staining, glycosaminoglycan (GAG) quantity, and diameter change.
Isolation/expansion under hypoxia resulted in faster BMSC population doublings per day (P <0.05), whereas cell and colony counts were not significantly different (P = 0.60 and 0.30, respectively). Collagen and HA scaffolds seeded with BMSCs that were isolated, expanded, and differentiated under hypoxia exhibited superior aggrecan and collagen II mRNA expressions (P <0.05), GAG quantity (P <0.05), and proteoglycan staining in comparison with normoxia. GAG/DNA was augmented with hypoxic isolation/expansion in all constructs (P <0.01). Comparison by scaffold composition indicated increased mRNA expressions of hyaline cartilage-associated collagen II, aggrecan, and SOX9 in collagen scaffolds, although expression of collagen X, which is related to hypertrophic cartilage, was also elevated (P <0.05). Proteoglycan deposition was not significantly improved in collagen scaffolds unless culture involved normoxic isolation/expansion followed by hypoxic differentiation. During chondrogenesis, collagen-based constructs progressively contracted to 60.1% ± 8.9% of the initial diameter after 14 days, whereas HA-based construct size was maintained (109.7% ± 4.2%).
Hypoxic isolation/expansion and differentiation enhance in vitro BMSC chondrogenesis within porous scaffolds. Although both collagen I and HA scaffolds support the creation of hyaline-like cartilaginous tissue, variations in gene expression, extracellular matrix formation, and construct size occur during chondrogenesis.
Bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stromal stem cells (BMSCs) are a promising cell-based option for treating articular cartilage defects [1-6]. Clinical and pre-clinical studies have shown variable outcomes following BMSC transplantation for treatment of focal chondral and osteochondral defects . Repair tissues consistent with hyaline cartilage, fibrocartilage, and mixed tissue have been reported [2-4]. Clinical scores correlate with quality of cartilaginous repair tissue on the basis of magnetic resonance imaging and histological analysis [2,4,6]. Therefore, culture conditions capable of improving cell and tissue phenotype are currently under investigation.
Incubator oxygen tension is a culture variable that has gained attention on the basis of the posited role of oxygen in musculoskeletal tissue development and cellular microenvironments. There is evidence to suggest that hypoxia promotes chondrogenic differentiation of BMSCs during pre-natal limb development . Furthermore, BMSCs exist in hypoxic bone marrow spaces, whereas chondrocytes reside within avascular hyaline cartilage and are bathed in hypoxic synovial fluid [9,10].
The positive impact of hypoxia on BMSC proliferation has been demonstrated on the basis of cell count, nucleoside incorporation, and colony-forming capability [11-15]. During prolonged expansion periods, stem cell characteristics such as rapid proliferation and multipotency are maintained with hypoxic incubation [11,12], whereas senescence is delayed . Hypoxic BMSC isolation and expansion [13-15,17,18] and hypoxic BMSC differentiation [12-15,17,19] have separately been associated with improved in vitro chondrogenesis within pellet, micromass, and hydrogel models. Three studies have compared the impact of hypoxic isolation/expansion with hypoxic differentiation on chondrogenesis, and variable improvements in gene expression and cartilaginous extracellular matrix (ECM) formation were found with hypoxic exposure during each distinct culture period [14,15,19].
Although hypoxic enhancement of BMSC chondrogenesis has been studied extensively in pellet, micromass, and hydrogel models, this effect has not been elucidated in detail in porous scaffolds. Porous scaffolds composed of natural and synthetic materials allow cells to permeate, adhere, and organize within a three-dimensional (3D) environment, and deposit ECM to form tissue . As a result, they serve as a suitable model for studying 3D cartilage formation in vitro . Moreover, porous scaffolds composed of collagen or hyaluronic acid (HA) are commonly used in clinical BMSC transplantation [2-5,21]. At present, it is not known whether hypoxic culture improves chondrogenesis of BMSCs seeded on 3D porous scaffolds. Accordingly, the first objective of this study was to assess the effect of oxygen tension during distinct isolation/expansion and differentiation culture periods on chondrogenesis within BMSC-seeded porous scaffolds. The impact of porous scaffold material on the modulation of chondrogenesis with oxygen tension has not been elucidated. Therefore, the second objective of this study was to investigate differences in chondrogenesis between BMSCs seeded and cultured on a collagen I porous scaffold and an esterified HA porous scaffold. It was hypothesized that hypoxic incubation during isolation/expansion and differentiation culture periods would improve BMSC chondrogenesis within each scaffold.
Bone marrow aspiration and mononucleated cell counting
Bone marrow donor information
Isolation and expansion of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells
Bone marrow aspirate collections containing 8 × 107 MNCs were seeded within each 150-cm2 tissue culture flask. Culture medium composed of alpha-minimal essential medium (α-MEM) supplemented with 10% vol/vol heat-inactivated fetal bovine serum (FBS), penicillin-streptomycin-glutamine, 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic acid (HEPES), and sodium pyruvate (all from Life Technologies, Burlington, ON, Canada) was pipetted into each flask. Fibroblast growth factor-2 (FGF-2) (Neuromics Inc., Edina, MN, USA) was added at a concentration of 5 ng/mL in order to maintain cell multipotency . Nucleated cells were allowed to adhere and grow for 7 days before the first media change under normoxia (ambient 21% O2) or hypoxia (low 3% O2) at 37°C in a humidified incubator containing 5% CO2. Flasks from the hypoxic incubator experienced short periods (<5 minutes) of normoxic exposure during media changes. Thereafter, the media were changed twice per week until 80% cell confluence was obtained. Adherent BMSCs were detached by using 0.05% wt/vol trypsin-ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) (Sigma-Aldrich, Oakville, ON, Canada) and expanded under the same oxygen tension (normoxia or hypoxia) as during isolation until passage 2 (P2) prior to scaffold seeding. Hereafter for brevity, BMSCs described by expansion oxygen tension alone (normoxia-expanded and hypoxia-expanded BMSCs) will refer to BMSCs that were isolated and expanded under normoxia and hypoxia, respectively. The time taken from plating of nucleated cells (P0) to reach approximately 80% confluence at P2, before experimental use, varied from 3 to 4 weeks.
Colony-forming unit fibroblastic assay
A colony-forming unit fibroblastic (CFU-F) assay was conducted to determine the effect of oxygen tension on colony-forming characteristics of BMSCs and to calculate the proportion of plastic-adherent cells (BMSCs) derived from bone marrow aspirates containing a known number of MNCs. MNCs from each donor were plated in triplicate at 1 × 105 MNCs per 100-mm-diameter sterile petri dish (Becton Dickinson Canada Inc.) and cultured as described for expansion conditions under normoxia (21% O2) or hypoxia (3% O2) by using α-MEM supplemented with 10% vol/vol heat-inactivated FBS, penicillin-streptomycin, HEPES, sodium pyruvate, and 5 ng/mL FGF-2. After the first week, the non-adherent cell population was removed by aspiration and culture media were replenished twice each week. During media changes, hypoxia-cultivated cells experienced a short period (<5 minutes) of exposure to normoxia. The total duration of culture time used for each donor (mean ± SEM of 16.3 ± 0.5 days) was equivalent to the time required to attain 80% BMSC confluence at P0 and subsequent detachment and splitting to P1 for expansion in T150 flasks (see ‘Isolation and expansion of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells’ section). For each donor, the culture times for petri dishes placed in hypoxic and normoxic conditions were identical. After the CFU-F culture period finished, the petri dishes were fixed with 10% wt/vol buffered formalin (3.8% wt/vol formaldehyde), washed by using phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) (Life Technologies), and stained with 0.25% wt/vol crystal violet solution (Sigma-Aldrich). During analysis, each stained cell collection was assessed and considered to be a colony only if (a) the cell collection was stained strongly with crystal violet, (b) the periphery of the collection was circular and well defined with respect to the surrounding area of the plate that was not stained, and (c) the diameter of the stained cell collection was measured to be at least 2 mm. The number of BMSC colonies in each dish was recorded, as was the diameter of each colony.
Bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell counts and doubling
Total cell counts of trypsinized BMSCs at P0, P1, and P2 were calculated by using trypan blue staining and hemocytometer counting of small aliquots of BMSCs in expansion medium. The number of colonies noted in each CFU-F assay was used to determine the number of BMSCs isolated per 1 × 105 MNCs plated for each donor, and this was extrapolated to calculate the number of BMSCs arising from 8 × 107 MNCs plated in each T150 culture flask during P0 expansion. Population doublings were determined by using the method described by Solchaga et al. .
Trilineage differentiation potential of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells
Osteogenic differentiation was performed by plating 5 × 103 BMSCs/cm2 within wells of a six-well plate (Becton Dickinson Canada Inc.) and culturing these in 2.5 mL of osteogenic medium for 21 days at 37°C in a humidified hypoxic incubator (3% O2 and 5% CO2). Osteogenic medium consisted of Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium (DMEM) containing 4.5 mg/mL D-glucose, 0.1 mM non-essential amino acids, 1 mM sodium pyruvate, 100 mM HEPES, 100 U/mL penicillin, 100 μg/mL streptomycin, 0.29 mg/mL L-glutamine (all from Life Technologies) supplemented with 10% vol/vol heat-inactivated FBS, 0.1 mM ascorbic acid 2-phosphate, 10 nM dexamethasone, and 10 mM β-glycerophosphate (Sigma-Aldrich). Media changes were performed twice per week. After the culture period, the contents of each well were fixed with 10% wt/vol buffered formalin (3.8% wt/vol formaldehyde), stained for 30 minutes with 1% wt/vol Alizarin Red S (Sigma-Aldrich) with an adjusted pH of 4.2, washed with distilled water over 60 minutes, and stored at 4°C in 70% vol/vol glycerol (Fisher Scientific Chemical Division, Fair Lawn, NJ, USA). Images were captured by using an Omano OM159T biological trinocular microscope (Microscope Store, Roanoke, VA, USA) fitted with an Optixcam Summit Series 5MP digital camera and Optixcam software and assembled in Photoshop (Adobe Systems Inc., San Jose, CA, USA).
Adipogenic differentiation was performed on BMSCs plated at 5 × 103 BMSCs/cm2 within wells of a six-well plate (Becton Dickinson Canada Inc.). Plated BMSCs were initially cultured in basic culture medium of 2.5 mL of DMEM containing 4.5 mg/mL D-glucose, 0.1 mM non-essential amino acids, 1 mM sodium pyruvate, 100 mM HEPES, 100 U/mL penicillin, 100 μg/mL streptomycin, and 0.29 mg/mL L-glutamine supplemented with 10% vol/vol heat-inactivated FBS (all from Life Technologies). Adipogenesis was then induced over the course of 3 days in 2.5 mL of basic culture medium supplemented with 1 μM dexamethasone, 0.5 mL insulin-transferrin-selenium (ITS) + 1, 100 μM indomethacin, and 500 μM isobutyl-1-methylxanthine (IBMX) (Sigma-Aldrich), followed by 1 day of culture in 2.5 mL of basic culture medium supplemented with only 0.5 mL ITS + 1. This 4-day cycle was repeated three times, followed by culture for 7 days in 2.5 mL of basic culture medium supplemented with only 0.5 mL ITS + 1. All culture was performed in a hypoxic humidified incubator (3% O2 and 5% CO2). After the culture period, the contents of each well were fixed with 10% wt/vol buffered formalin (3.8% wt/vol formaldehyde), stained for 60 minutes with 0.3% wt/vol Oil Red O (Sigma-Aldrich), washed with distilled water, and assessed immediately for staining. Oil Red O solution was prepared by creating a 0.5% wt/vol solution of Oil Red O (Sigma-Aldrich) in isopropanol (Fisher Scientific Chemical Division) and then diluting this to 0.3% wt/vol in an equivalent volume of distilled water. Microscopic images were captured in an identical fashion to osteogenic culture products.
Chondrogenic differentiation was verified by using a pellet culture system. BMSCs were suspended in chondrogenic medium consisting of DMEM containing 4.5 mg/mL D-glucose, 0.1 mM non-essential amino acids, 1 mM sodium pyruvate, 100 mM HEPES, 100 U/mL penicillin, 100 μg/mL streptomycin, 0.29 mg/mL L-glutamine (all from Life Technologies) supplemented with 0.1 mM ascorbic acid 2-phosphate, 0.1 μM dexamethasone, 1x ITS + 1 premix (Sigma-Aldrich), and 10 ng/mL transforming growth factor-beta 3 (TGF-β3) (Neuromics Inc.). In total, 5 × 105 BMSCs were spun within 1.5-mL sterile conical polypropylene microfuge tubes (Enzymax LLC, Lexington, KY, USA) at 1,500 revolutions per minute for 5 minutes to form spherical cell pellets. Pellets were then submersed in 500 μL of chondrogenic medium and cultured in a hypoxic humidified incubator (3% O2 and 5% CO2) for 21 days. Pellets experienced a short period (<5 minutes) of exposure to normal oxygen tension during media changes. After the culture period, BMSC pellets were processed and stained for histological analysis of cartilaginous proteoglycans (see ‘Histological and immunohistochemical analyses of extracellular matrix contents’ section).
Porous scaffold seeding and chondrogenic differentiation of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell-seeded scaffolds
Cylindrical collagen scaffolds (3.5-mm thickness and 6-mm diameter) were created by using a biopsy punch on sheets of porous, type I collagen sponge (125 × 100 × 3.5 mm3 dimension and 115 ± 20 μm pore size; Integra LifeSciences Corp., Plainsboro Township, NJ, USA). Cylindrical HA scaffolds (2-mm thickness and 6-mm diameter) were created by using a biopsy punch on sheets of esterified HA (HYAFF) non-woven mesh (20 × 20 × 2 mm3 dimensions and 10- to 20-μm-diameter fibers with varying inter-fiber spaces ; Anika Therapeutics S.r.l., Abano Terme, PD, Italy). Scaffold seeding was performed at a consistent density of 1 × 107 BMSCs/cm3, which corresponded to 989,602 BMSCs seeded per collagen scaffold and 565,487 BMSCs seeded per HA scaffold .
During seeding, BMSCs at P2 were re-suspended in chondrogenic culture medium (see ‘Trilineage differentiation potential of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells’ section). Total cell counts were calculated from trypan blue staining and hemocytometer counting of small aliquots of BMSCs. BMSCs were micropipetted onto each scaffold within a 20-μL chondrogenic medium suspension. HA scaffolds were pre-soaked with 20 μL of chondrogenic medium to promote dispersion of the cell suspension over the scaffold during seeding. Seeded scaffolds were then incubated at 37°C for 15 minutes followed by the addition of 100 μL of chondrogenic medium to the base of each scaffold. Thereafter, constructs were incubated for an additional 30 minutes to promote cell adhesion. All constructs, including cell-free scaffolds (control group) and those seeded with either normoxia- or hypoxia-expanded BMSCs, were subsequently immersed in 1 mL of chondrogenic medium and cultured statically at 37°C within humidified incubators containing 5% CO2 and either 21% O2 (normoxia) or 3% O2 (hypoxia). Media were changed twice weekly thereafter.
Oxygen tension experimental groups
Reverse transcription-quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction analysis of chondrogenic genes
Ovine primer sequences used in reverse transcription-quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction analysis
Collagen I (COL1A1)
Collagen II (COL2A1)
Collagen X (COL10A1)
SRY-Box 9 (SOX9)
RT-qPCR products were subsequently sequenced to confirm that expression levels were based on appropriate sequences for each gene. For sequencing, RT-qPCR products were purified by using a QIAquick Gel Extraction Kit (Qiagen Inc. Canada, Toronto, ON, Canada), combined with each primer (forward and reverse primers separately), and sequenced by using the Sanger method (The Applied Genomics Centre, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada). The resulting traces were read by using FinchTV Software Version 1.5 (Geospiza Inc., Seattle, WA, USA) and matched to corresponding regions within characterized gene sequences by using the nucleotide Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) (NCBI). Sequencing analysis is included within Additional file 1.
Histological and immunohistochemical analyses of extracellular matrix contents
Pellets and scaffold-based constructs were removed from media, fixed in 10% wt/vol buffered formalin (3.8% wt/vol formaldehyde), processed into paraffin wax, and sectioned at a thickness of 5 μm. Sections were stained with 0.1% wt/vol safranin O to reveal proteoglycan matrix depositions and counterstained with 1% wt/vol fast green. Other sections from scaffold-based constructs were treated with chondroitinase (Sigma-Aldrich) at 0.2 U per section and incubated with an antibody against collagen II (II-II6B3 from Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank at the University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, USA; 1:50 dilution). Immune-localized antigens were visualized with horse anti-mouse IgG biotinylated secondary antibody (Vectastain; Vector Laboratories Inc., Burlingame, CA, USA) and an aminoethylcarbazole (AEC)-based peroxidase labeling kit (Enzo Life Sciences Inc., Farmingdale, NY, USA). Images were captured by using an Eclipse Ti-S microscope (Nikon Canada Inc., Mississauga, ON, Canada) fitted with NIS Elements Basic Research Imaging Software Version 4.20 (Nikon Canada Inc.) and assembled in Photoshop.
Biochemical analysis of glycosaminoglycan and DNA quantity
In vitro cultured BMSC-scaffold constructs were rinsed in PBS and digested in proteinase K (1 mg/mL in 50 mM Tris with 1 mM EDTA, 1 mM iodoacetamide, and 10 mg/mL pepstatin A; all from Sigma-Aldrich) for 16 hours at 56°C. Sulfated GAG content was measured by 1,9-dimethylmethylene blue binding (Sigma-Aldrich) by using chondroitin sulfate (Sigma-Aldrich) as the standard. DNA content was determined by using the CyQUANT Cell Proliferation Assay Kit (Life Technologies) with supplied bacteriophage λ DNA as the standard.
Analysis of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell-scaffold construct size
To characterize changes in diameter with culture time, BMSC-seeded scaffolds (five per donor) were photographed with a high-quality digital camera after 7 and 14 days of in vitro chondrogenic culture. Each image was evaluated for diameter changes as previously described [26,27]. The diameter of each scaffold was measured in four separate planes with ImageJ software (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA), and the resulting mean diameter was expressed as a percentage change from the initial diameter at the time of seeding .
Analyses were performed by using SPSS Statistics 22 (IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY, USA), and a P value of less than 0.05 was considered significant. Proliferation analyses used a repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) for BMSC count and doublings over time, and a t test was used for assessment of these parameters on specific culture days. CFU-F analysis involved a Mann-Whitney U test for assessment of colony count and diameter. For analyses of gene expression and biochemical quantities, a Kruskal-Wallis one-way ANOVA was used to determine differences between the four experimental groups with pairwise (post hoc) comparisons, and a Mann-Whitney U test was used for pooled analyses. For analysis of construct diameter, a repeated measures ANOVA was used to determine differences between the four experimental groups over time, and a t test was used for pooled analysis at each time point.
All experiments were implemented with BMSCs isolated from bone marrow aspirates taken from adult sheep after ethical approval from the University of Alberta’s Animal Care and Use Committee.
Hypoxic isolation and expansion to passage 2 may enhance bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell proliferation
Trilineage differentiation of adherent bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells
Plastic-adherent BMSCs were expanded to P2 and differentiated in vitro toward bone, adipose, and cartilage tissue lineages to confirm multilineage potential . Tissue derived from BMSCs stained extensively with Alizarin Red S (Figure 2D) and Oil Red O (Figure 2E), which confirmed the presence of bone and adipose matrix following culture in defined osteogenic and adipogenic media, respectively. Positive safranin O staining of sections from BMSC pellets and cell-seeded scaffolds following culture in chondrogenic medium supported the chondrogenic capacity of the adherent cells (Figure 2F).
Hypoxic isolation/expansion and differentiation augment chondrogenic gene expression differentially within bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell-seeded collagen and hyaluronic acid scaffolds
To further characterize the impact of oxygen tension on gene expression, data were pooled on the basis of expansion oxygen tension and differentiation oxygen tension. BMSCs expanded under hypoxic conditions and seeded within collagen scaffolds produced significantly higher mRNA expression of collagen II and increased ratios of collagen II/I and collagen II/X than BMSCs expanded under normoxic conditions (P <0.01; Figure 4H). However, aggrecan expression was not significantly different between groups (P = 0.19; Figure 4G). HA scaffolds seeded with BMSCs expanded under hypoxia produced significantly higher mRNA expression of aggrecan than BMSCs expanded under normoxia (P = 0.02; Figure 4G). Collagen II mRNA expression and ratios of collagen II/I and collagen II/X were not significantly different (P = 0.31 and 0.74, respectively; Figure 4H). Within both collagen- and HA-based constructs, oxygen tension during expansion did not significantly impact collagen I, collagen X, COMP, or SOX9 mRNA expression (P ≥0.29, 0.52, 0.14, and 0.16, respectively).
Pooling of data on the basis of differentiation condition indicated that hypoxic differentiation also augmented chondrogenic gene expression. Collagen scaffolds seeded with BMSCs and differentiated under hypoxia had significantly higher aggrecan and collagen I mRNA expressions (P = 0.008 and 0.03; Figure 4G) and approached statistically significant higher degrees of collagen II expression (P = 0.09; Figure 4H). Collagen X mRNA expression was marginally lower with hypoxic differentiation (P = 0.06). SOX9 and COMP mRNA expressions and the ratios of collagen II/I and collagen II/X were not significantly different between groups (P = 0.20, 0.02, 0.28, and 0.13, respectively). HA scaffolds seeded with BMSCs and differentiated under hypoxia had significantly higher mRNA expressions of aggrecan and collagen II (P <0.05; Figure 4G and H) and an increased collagen II/I ratio that approached significance (P = 0.09). SOX9, COMP, collagen I, and collagen X mRNA expressions and the ratio of collagen II/X were not significantly different between hypoxic and normoxic differentiation (P = 0.62, 0.28, 0.99, 0.31, and 0.13, respectively).
Scaffold composition modulated chondrogenic gene expression of BMSCs. BMSC-seeded collagen scaffolds had notably higher expressions of aggrecan, collagen II, and SOX9 genes than BMSC-seeded HA scaffolds in the majority of oxygen tension groups (P <0.05; Figure 4A, D, and F). Within pooled data, BMSCs seeded within collagen scaffolds had augmented aggrecan, collagen II, SOX9, and collagen X gene expressions relative to BMSCs seeded within HA scaffolds regardless of expansion or differentiation oxygen tension (P <0.01; Figure 4G, H, and I). Collagen I gene expression was not significantly different between scaffolds under hypoxic expansion, normoxic expansion, or normoxic differentiation (P ≥0.18). However, under hypoxic differentiation, collagen I expression was significantly higher in BMSCs seeded within collagen scaffolds relative to HA scaffolds (P = 0.03). COMP gene expression was significantly increased in BMSCs seeded on collagen scaffolds only when expansion and differentiation were performed under hypoxia (P <0.01).
Hypoxic isolation/expansion and differentiation enhance chondrogenic extracellular matrix deposition differentially within bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell-seeded collagen and hyaluronic acid scaffolds
Within HA scaffolds, pockets of ECM were found around HA fibers, which led to the creation of patchy tissue after 14 days of culture (Figure 5). BMSCs that were isolated and expanded under hypoxia demonstrated the most pronounced safranin O staining (Hyp/Hyp and Hyp/Nrx). Although ECM was also noted within HA scaffolds seeded with BMSCs that underwent isolation/expansion under normoxia (Nrx/Hyp and Nrx/Nrx), these constructs lacked safranin O staining. Hypoxic differentiation appeared to augment proteoglycan content in hypoxia-expanded BMSC-seeded HA scaffolds (Hyp/Hyp) but not normoxia-expanded BMSC-seeded HA scaffolds (Nrx/Hyp). Immunohistochemistry revealed the presence of collagen II within ECM in constructs that were exposed to hypoxia during the culture period (Figure 6).
Scaffold composition had a notable effect on ECM proteoglycan deposition. In a comparison of collagen and HA scaffold-based constructs within each oxygen tension group, a significant difference was seen only in the Nrx/Hyp group in which BMSC-seeded collagen scaffolds had higher GAG and GAG/DNA than BMSC-seeded HA scaffolds (P <0.05; Figure 7A and C). Collagen scaffolds that were seeded with normoxia-expanded BMSCs but switched to hypoxic conditions for differentiation (Nrx/Hyp) appeared to have improved GAG/DNA relative to BMSCs that were exposed to sustained normoxic conditions (Nrx/Nrx; P = 0.18; Figure 7C). This finding was supported by proteoglycans stained within BMSC-seeded collagen scaffolds (Figure 5). This effect was not seen in BMSC-seeded HA scaffolds, as Nrx/Hyp constructs had stunted GAG/DNA values that were statistically equivalent to Nrx/Nrx constructs (P = 0.97) and significantly lower than Hyp/Hyp and Hyp/Nrx constructs (P <0.05; Figure 7C). Pooled data showed higher proteoglycan deposition by cells seeded on collagen scaffolds in comparison with HA scaffolds only when expansion was performed under normoxia (P = 0.03 and 0.04 for GAG and GAG/DNA, respectively; Figure 7D and F) and when differentiation was performed under hypoxia (P = 0.02 for GAG; Figure 7D).
Oxygen tension and scaffold composition modulate cell-scaffold construct size during chondrogenesis
In contrast to collagen scaffold-based constructs, HA scaffold-based constructs increased in size to 109.7% ± 4.2% of the initial diameter (P <0.001; Figure 8B). A significant difference was noted between oxygen tension groups at days 7 and 14 (P ≤0.003). Based on pooled analysis, expansion oxygen tension affected HA scaffolds similarly to collagen scaffolds (Figure 8D). Although there was not a significant difference between hypoxia- and normoxia-expanded BMSC-seeded scaffolds at day 7 (113.0% ± 0.8% and 111.3% ± 0.9%, respectively; P = 0.15), an effect became statistically significant by day 14 in which hypoxic expansion led to increased diameters relative to normoxic expansion (110.9% ± 0.7% and 108.4% ± 0.8%, respectively; P = 0.02). Like BMSC-seeded collagen scaffolds, BMSC-seeded HA scaffolds that were differentiated under hypoxia were more contracted (109.5% ± 0.7%) than BMSC scaffold differentiated under normoxia at day 7 (114.8% ± 0.7%; P <0.001). This effect was also seen at day 14 (108.2% ± 0.7% versus 111.1% ± 0.7%; P = 0.006).
The major findings of this study are that incubation of ovine BMSCs under hypoxia (3% O2) during isolation/expansion and differentiation enhanced in vitro chondrogenesis within clinically approved porous collagen I and esterified HA scaffolds and that porous scaffold composition impacted the effect of oxygen tension on chondrogenesis in this in vitro model.
Enhancement of chondrogenesis by hypoxic culture was elucidated in BMSC-seeded porous scaffolds, which is an important finding given that cell-seeded scaffolds are used routinely as 3D models of in vitro chondrogenesis and clinically in cell transplantation protocols for treatment of cartilage defects [7,21]. It was shown that chondrogenesis could be promoted with hypoxic exposure during distinct isolation/expansion and differentiation conditions. Although oxygen tension during distinct isolation/expansion and differentiation periods was previously studied in detail within pellet and hydrogel models in three studies, the results were inconsistent and warranted further investigation [14,15,19]. In the study at hand, hyaline chondrogenic gene expression of BMSC-seeded porous scaffolds was enhanced with hypoxic exposure during both isolation/expansion and differentiation. This is consistent with our previous findings in a human BMSC pellet model . ECM proteoglycan and collagen II deposition was significantly improved with hypoxic isolation/expansion based on histological and biochemical analyses, whereas the impact of hypoxic differentiation appeared to be less pronounced in this study. Although this finding was demonstrated previously in human BMSC pellets , others have reported highly significant findings following hypoxic differentiation in human BMSC pellet  and porcine BMSC pellet and hydrogel  models. Differences in the effect of hypoxic differentiation between studies could relate to variations in species, duration of incubation, or culture protocols or a combination of these.
BMSC proliferation was also examined, and it was found that hypoxic isolation and expansion to P2 only modestly improved BMSC proliferation. Increased population doublings per day were noted with hypoxic exposure. However, BMSC counts at each passage, cumulative population doublings, and CFU-F colony counts were not significantly different between oxygen tension groups. These results are consistent with previous work that showed non-significant differences during early passages and enhanced proliferation under hypoxia only with prolonged expansion beyond P2 [11,12].
Collagen and HA porous scaffolds were assessed in this study given that these biomaterials are commonly used in cartilage engineering applications and clinical BMSC transplantation [1,2,4,5]. Both scaffolds were capable of fostering gene expression and ECM formation consistent with hyaline-like cartilage from BMSCs cultured in vitro. Chondrogenesis on collagen and HA scaffolds was responsive to oxygen tension. However, differences were noted between scaffolds in BMSC gene expression, ECM deposition, and construct size during differentiation. BMSCs seeded and cultured within collagen scaffolds had higher expressions of aggrecan, collagen II, and SOX9 mRNA than BMSCs within HA scaffolds regardless of oxygen tension, which suggests that BMSC differentiation on collagen increases the expression of genes associated with hyaline cartilage relative to the HA. However, BMSCs within collagen scaffolds also had higher mRNA expression of collagen X regardless of oxygen tension and higher expression of collagen I under hypoxic differentiation. These findings suggest that culture on an HA scaffold could modulate gene expression more favorably for hyaline cartilage regeneration by reducing the expression of collagens I and X, which are associated with fibrocartilage and hypertrophic cartilage [29,30] while maintaining the expression of genes associated with hyaline cartilage. Differences between scaffolds were not as pronounced for ECM deposition as gene expression. In most oxygen tension groups, proteoglycan content was not significantly different between collagen- and HA-based constructs. BMSC-seeded collagen scaffolds had higher proteoglycan deposition specifically when expansion was performed under normoxia and differentiation was performed under hypoxia. Hypoxic differentiation appeared to partially reverse dampening of chondrogenesis by normoxic isolation/expansion on BMSC-seeded collagen scaffolds but not on BMSC-seeded HA scaffolds.
The underlying mechanisms for modulation of chondrogenic gene expression and tissue formation by scaffold type were not elucidated in this study but warrant further investigation. BMSCs interact with collagen scaffolds via integrins and with HA scaffolds through CD44 [31,32]. Scaffold characteristics such as stiffness, biomaterial topography, and pore dimension presumably alter intracellular signaling and subsequent processes related to chondrogenesis through these cell surface proteins . Matrix stiffness was found previously to regulate BMSC differentiation and tissue formation . Topographical factors such as scaffold fiber alignment and nanoscale surface features have been shown to influence cell lineage commitment [34,35]. Furthermore, content, size, and orientation of scaffold pores appear to affect BMSC differentiation [36,37]. Porosity alters oxygen diffusion through scaffolds, which could also modulate chondrogenesis through the creation of oxygen gradients .
BMSC-scaffold construct diameter was investigated during culture given that fluctuations in construct size occur with tissue formation and remodeling and ultimately impact the suitability for constructs for implantation in vivo. Size was maintained during culture in BMSC-seeded HA scaffolds, whereas BMSC-seeded collagen scaffolds exhibited progressive contraction with time. Variation in size presumably involves a balance of cell-scaffold interactions, biomaterial chemistry, scaffold degradation, and ECM formation. Cell-mediated contraction that occurs through smooth muscle actin has been described in detail within collagen-based constructs . HA is hydrophilic and may promote increased scaffold swelling through water absorption relative to collagen I . Biomaterial degradation, hydrolysis, or fragmentation may reduce the size of a construct if an adequate amount of ECM has not been deposited by the time that these processes occur [23,40,41]. In the study at hand, it is not known how scaffold size affected chondrogenesis, although collagen scaffold contraction presumably led to increased cell density per volume of scaffold, which could have modulated cell-cell interactions and increased chondrogenesis . It is also possible that contraction inhibited chondrogenesis, as it was shown previously that contraction may promote differentiation to a fibroblastic lineage [43,44]. Given that esterified HA scaffold size was maintained, the findings of this study suggest that, in a clinical setting, implantation of BMSCs on an esterified HA scaffold could promote better early cartilage defect filling than on a collagen scaffold.
Construct size was also affected by incubator oxygen tension. Both collagen and HA scaffold seeded with BMSCs had increased diameters when BMSC isolation and expansion were performed under hypoxia and differentiation was performed under normoxia. Various mechanisms could be involved: modulation of cell-mediated contraction through smooth muscle actin and cytoskeletal alteration , ECM proteoglycan formation [14,45], crosslinking via lysyl oxidase , or degradation through matrix metalloproteinases .
This study has some limitations. Although two defining criteria of mesenchymal stem cells—plastic adherence and multipotential differentiation—were confirmed, determination of cell surface antigens was not performed to fulfill the third criterion of the Mesenchymal and Tissue Stem Cell Committee . This third criterion was omitted because the study at hand involved an identical method of BMSC isolation and expansion described in our previous work, which included flow cytometric analysis of cell surface markers . Secondly, the findings of this study demonstrate enhanced in vitro chondrogenesis with hypoxic culture, although it is still not clear whether in vitro hypoxic culture improves chondrogenesis following implantation within cartilage defects and prolonged in vivo exposure to joint elements. Joints have been shown to be hypoxic, and it is possible that this characteristic could promote in vivo chondrogenesis regardless of the in vitro culture conditions prior to construct implantation . Lastly, ovine rather than human BMSCs were used in this study. Although sheep are routinely used as animal models in cartilage engineering studies [13,48,49], differences between species could impact the clinical applicability of our findings.
BMSCs seeded on clinically relevant collagen I and esterified HA porous scaffolds displayed enhanced in vitro chondrogenesis with hypoxic incubation during distinct isolation/expansion and differentiation culture periods. Hypoxic culture of BMSCs may therefore play a role in improving cartilaginous tissue formation following transplantation of BMSC-seeded scaffolds. Both collagen I and esterified HA scaffold supported the creation of hyaline-like engineered cartilage. However, differences were noted in chondrogenic gene expression, ECM deposition, and cell-scaffold construct size during differentiation that could impact the choice of biomaterial for use in BMSC transplantation protocols.
alpha-minimal essential medium
analysis of variance
bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell
colony-forming unit fibroblastic
cartilage oligomeric matrix protein
Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium
fetal bovine serum
fibroblast growth factor-2
National Center for Biotechnology Information
reverse transcription-quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction
standard error of the mean
sex-determining region Y (SRY)-box 9
Financial support was provided by the University Hospital Foundation at the University of Alberta Hospital, Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR MOP 125921), and the Edmonton Orthopaedic Research Committee. Integra LifeSciences Corp. supplied the collagen scaffold, and Anika Therapeutics S.r.l. supplied the HA scaffold for this study. We thank Thomas Churchill for providing us with photography and histology equipment and Craig Wilkinson and Brenda Tchir for their involvement in animal monitoring and care.
- Wakitani S, Nawata M, Tensho K, Okabe T, Machida H, Ohgushi H. Repair of articular cartilage defects in the patello-femoral joint with autologous bone marrow mesenchymal cell transplantation: three case reports involving nine defects in five knees. J Tissue Eng Regen Med. 2007;1:74–9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Buda R, Vannini F, Cavallo M, Grigolo B, Cenacchi A, Giannini S. Osteochondral lesions of the knee: a new one-step repair technique with bone-marrow-derived cells. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2010;92:2–11.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Gobbi A, Karnatzikos G, Scotti C, Mahajan M, Mazzucco L, Grigolo B. One-step cartilage repair with bone marrow aspirate concentrated cells and collagen matrix in full-thickness knee cartilage lesions: results at 2-year follow-up. Cartilage. 2011;2:286–99.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Giannini S, Buda R, Battaglia M, Cavallo M, Ruffilli A, Ramponi L, et al. One-step repair in talar osteochondral lesions: 4-year clinical results and t2-mapping capability in outcome prediction. Am J Sports Med. 2013;41:511–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kasemkijwattana C, Hongeng S, Kesprayura S, Rungsinaporn V, Chaipinyo K, Chansiri K. Autologous bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells implantation for cartilage defects: two cases report. J Med Assoc Thai. 2011;94:395–400.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Enea D, Cecconi S, Calcagno S, Busilacchi A, Manzotti S, Kaps C, et al. Single-stage cartilage repair in the knee with microfracture covered with a resorbable polymer-based matrix and autologous bone marrow concentrate. Knee. 2013;20:562–9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bornes TD, Adesida AB, Jomha NM. Mesenchymal stem cells in the treatment of traumatic articular cartilage defects: a comprehensive review. Arthritis Res Ther. 2014;16:432.View ArticlePubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Leijten JC, Moreira Teixeira LS, Landman EB, van Blitterswijk CA, Karperien M. Hypoxia inhibits hypertrophic differentiation and endochondral ossification in explanted tibiae. PLoS One. 2012;7, e49896.View ArticlePubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Harrison JS, Rameshwar P, Chang V, Bandari P. Oxygen saturation in the bone marrow of healthy volunteers. Blood. 2002;99:394.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lund-Olesen K. Oxygen tension in synovial fluids. Arthritis Rheum. 1970;13:769–76.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Grayson WL, Zhao F, Bunnell B, Ma T. Hypoxia enhances proliferation and tissue formation of human mesenchymal stem cells. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2007;358:948–53.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tsai CC, Chen YJ, Yew TL, Chen LL, Wang JY, Chiu CH, et al. Hypoxia inhibits senescence and maintains mesenchymal stem cell properties through down-regulation of E2A-p21 by HIF-TWIST. Blood. 2011;117:459–69.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zscharnack M, Poesel C, Galle J, Bader A. Low oxygen expansion improves subsequent chondrogenesis of ovine bone-marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells in collagen type I hydrogel. Cells Tissues Organs. 2009;190:81–93.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Adesida AB, Mulet-Sierra A, Jomha NM. Hypoxia mediated isolation and expansion enhances the chondrogenic capacity of bone marrow mesenchymal stromal cells. Stem Cell Res Ther. 2012;3:9.View ArticlePubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sheehy EJ, Buckley CT, Kelly DJ. Oxygen tension regulates the osteogenic, chondrogenic and endochondral phenotype of bone marrow derived mesenchymal stem cells. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2012;417:305–10.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Moussavi-Harami F, Duwayri Y, Martin JA, Moussavi-Harami F, Buckwalter JA. Oxygen effects on senescence in chondrocytes and mesenchymal stem cells: consequences for tissue engineering. Iowa Orthop J. 2004;24:15–20.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Muller J, Benz K, Ahlers M, Gaissmaier C, Mollenhauer J. Hypoxic conditions during expansion culture prime human mesenchymal stromal precursor cells for chondrogenic differentiation in three-dimensional cultures. Cell Transplant. 2011;20:1589–602.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Leijten J, Georgi N, Moreira Teixeira L, van Blitterswijk CA, Post JN, Karperien M. Metabolic programming of mesenchymal stromal cells by oxygen tension directs chondrogenic cell fate. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2014;111:13954–9.View ArticlePubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Boyette LB, Creasey OA, Guzik L, Lozito T, Tuan RS. Human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells display enhanced clonogenicity but impaired differentiation with hypoxic preconditioning. Stem Cells Transl Med. 2014;3:241–54.View ArticlePubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Garg T, Singh O, Arora S, Murthy R. Scaffold: a novel carrier for cell and drug delivery. Crit Rev Ther Drug Carrier Syst. 2012;29:1–63.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Filardo G, Kon E, Roffi A, Di Martino A, Marcacci M. Scaffold-based repair for cartilage healing: a systematic review and technical note. Arthroscopy. 2013;29:174–86.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Solchaga LA, Penick K, Goldberg VM, Caplan AI, Welter JF. Fibroblast growth factor-2 enhances proliferation and delays loss of chondrogenic potential in human adult bone-marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells. Tissue Eng Part A. 2010;16:1009–19.View ArticlePubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pasquinelli G, Orrico C, Foroni L, Bonafe F, Carboni M, Guarnieri C, et al. Mesenchymal stem cell interaction with a non-woven hyaluronan-based scaffold suitable for tissue repair. J Anat. 2008;213:520–30.
- Hunziker EB, Quinn TM, Hauselmann HJ. Quantitative structural organization of normal adult human articular cartilage. Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 2002;10:564–72.
- Livak KJ, Schmittgen TD. Analysis of relative gene expression data using real-time quantitative PCR and the 2(−Delta Delta C(T)) Method. Methods. 2001;25:402–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lee CR, Grodzinsky AJ, Spector M. Modulation of the contractile and biosynthetic activity of chondrocytes seeded in collagen-glycosaminoglycan matrices. Tissue Eng. 2003;9:27–36.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- McMahon LA, Reid AJ, Campbell VA, Prendergast PJ. Regulatory effects of mechanical strain on the chondrogenic differentiation of MSCs in a collagen-GAG scaffold: experimental and computational analysis. Ann Biomed Eng. 2008;36:185–94.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dominici M, Le Blanc K, Mueller I, Slaper-Cortenbach I, Marini F, Krause D, et al. Minimal criteria for defining multipotent mesenchymal stromal cells. The International Society for Cellular Therapy position statement. Cytotherapy. 2006;8:315–7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Studer D, Millan C, Ozturk E, Maniura-Weber K, Zenobi-Wong M. Molecular and biophysical mechanisms regulating hypertrophic differentiation in chondrocytes and mesenchymal stem cells. Eur Cell Mater. 2012;24:118–35. Discussion 135.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Demoor M, Maneix L, Ollitrault D, Legendre F, Duval E, Claus S, et al. Deciphering chondrocyte behaviour in matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation to undergo accurate cartilage repair with hyaline matrix. Pathol Biol (Paris). 2012;60:199–207.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Leitinger B, Hohenester E. Mammalian collagen receptors. Matrix Biol. 2007;26:146–55.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Peach RJ, Hollenbaugh D, Stamenkovic I, Aruffo A. Identification of hyaluronic acid binding sites in the extracellular domain of CD44. J Cell Biol. 1993;122:257–64.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Engler AJ, Sen S, Sweeney HL, Discher DE. Matrix elasticity directs stem cell lineage specification. Cell. 2006;126:677–89.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yin Z, Chen X, Song HX, Hu JJ, Tang QM, Zhu T, et al. Electrospun scaffolds for multiple tissues regeneration in vivo through topography dependent induction of lineage specific differentiation. Biomaterials. 2015;44:173–85.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dalby MJ, Gadegaard N, Tare R, Andar A, Riehle MO, Herzyk P, et al. The control of human mesenchymal cell differentiation using nanoscale symmetry and disorder. Nat Mater. 2007;6:997–1003.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chen G, Lv Y, Dong C, Yang L. Effect of internal structure of collagen/hydroxyapatite scaffold on the osteogenic differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells. Curr Stem Cell Res Ther. 2015;10:99–108.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Phadke A, Hwang Y, Kim SH, Kim SH, Yamaguchi T, Masuda K, et al. Effect of scaffold microarchitecture on osteogenic differentiation of human mesenchymal stem cells. Eur Cell Mater. 2013;25:114–28. Discussion 128–9.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fiedler T, Belova IV, Murch GE, Poologasundarampillai G, Jones JR, Roether JA, et al. A comparative study of oxygen diffusion in tissue engineering scaffolds. J Mater Sci Mater Med. 2014;25:2573–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kinner B, Spector M. Smooth muscle actin expression by human articular chondrocytes and their contraction of a collagen-glycosaminoglycan matrix in vitro. J Orthop Res. 2001;19:233–41.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Okada T, Hayashi T, Ikada Y. Degradation of collagen suture in vitro and in vivo. Biomaterials. 1992;13:448–54.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Shingleton WD, Hodges DJ, Brick P, Cawston TE. Collagenase: a key enzyme in collagen turnover. Biochem Cell Biol. 1996;74:759–75.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Caplan AI. Effects of the nicotinamide-sensitive teratogen3-acetylpyridine on chick limb cells in culture. Exp Cell Res. 1970;62:341–55.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Awad HA, Butler DL, Harris MT, Ibrahim RE, Wu Y, Young RG, et al. In vitro characterization of mesenchymal stem cell-seeded collagen scaffolds for tendon repair: effects of initial seeding density on contraction kinetics. J Biomed Mater Res. 2000;51:233–40.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Francioli SE, Candrian C, Martin K, Heberer M, Martin I, Barbero A. Effect of three-dimensional expansion and cell seeding density on the cartilage-forming capacity of human articular chondrocytes in type II collagen sponges. J Biomed Mater Res A. 2010;95:924–31.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pearle AD, Warren RF, Rodeo SA. Basic science of articular cartilage and osteoarthritis. Clin Sports Med. 2005;24:1–12.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Makris EA, Hu JC, Athanasiou KA. Hypoxia-induced collagen crosslinking as a mechanism for enhancing mechanical properties of engineered articular cartilage. Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 2013;21:634–41.View ArticlePubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ronziere MC, Perrier E, Mallein-Gerin F, Freyria AM. Chondrogenic potential of bone marrow- and adipose tissue-derived adult human mesenchymal stem cells. Biomed Mater Eng. 2010;20:145–58.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zscharnack M, Hepp P, Richter R, Aigner T, Schulz R, Somerson J, et al. Repair of chronic osteochondral defects using predifferentiated mesenchymal stem cells in an ovine model. Am J Sports Med. 2010;38:1857–69.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Schinhan M, Gruber M, Vavken P, Dorotka R, Samouh L, Chiari C, et al. Critical-size defect induces unicompartmental osteoarthritis in a stable ovine knee. J Orthop Res. 2012;30:214–20.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.