Skip to main content

Table 3 Summary of subgroup analysis of stem cells for the treatment of patients with CD

From: Systematic review with meta-analysis: the efficacy and safety of stem cell therapy for Crohn’s disease

 

Clinical response

Clinical remission

Fistula closure

Items

n

Heterogeneity

ES

95% CI

n

Heterogeneity

ES

95% CI

n

Heterogeneity

ES

95% CI

 

I 2

P

   

I 2

P

   

I 2

P

 

Overall

11

78.6%

<0.001

0.56

[0.33–0.76]

8

68.5%

0.002

0.46

[0.25–0.69]

12

59.9%

0.003

0.57

[0.44–0.69]

Source

 HSC

0

-

-

-

-

4

75.9%

0.006

0.73

[0.36–0.93]

2

80.8%

0.022

0.29

[0.03–0.85]

 BMSC

6

69.8%

0.005

0.59

[0.34–0.80]

4

60.1%

0.057

0.23

[0.07–0.54]

2

0.0%

0.740

0.60

[0.44–0.75]

 ASC

5

84.6%

<0.001

0.51

[0.13–0.88]

0

-

-

-

-

9

65.3%

0.003

0.62

[0.42–0.79]

Source

 Autologous

7

49.6%

0.064

0.31

[0.17–0.49]

5

76.4%

0.002

0.61

[0.25–0.88]

9

59.5%

0.011

0.62

[0.44–0.77]

 Allogeneic

4

26.7%

0.251

0.86

[0.71–0.94]

3

56%

0.103

0.32

[0.11–0.62]

4

30.2%

0.231

0.47

[0.33–0.61]

Routine

 Systemic

5

67.7%

0.001

0.66

[0.39–0.86]

8

68.5%

0.002

0.46

[0.25–0.69]

2

80.8%

0.023

0.29

[0.03–0.85]

 Local

6

81.0%

<0.001

0.45

[0.16–0.79]

0

-

-

-

-

11

57.9%

0.002

0.60

[0.47–0.72]

  1. Abbreviations: ASC adipose-derived mesenchymal stem cell, BMSC bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell, HSC hematopoietic stem cell