Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies

From: Mesenchymal stem cells against intestinal ischemia–reperfusion injury: a systematic review and meta-analysis of preclinical studies

Author

Year

Country

Species/gender

Age/weight

I/R duration

Anesthetic

MSCs type /dosage

Administration

Timing of MSCs (post-reperfusion)

AMI

2017

Turkey

SD rats/f

200–250 g

45 min/1, 4, 7 d

Xylazine/ketamine

BM, allogeneic, 0.5/1 × 106

Inferior vena cava/local injection

Immediately

Chang

2015

Taiwan

SD rats/m

325–350 g

30 min/3 d

Unclear

AD, autologous, 1.2 × 106

Intravenous and local injection

Immediately

Fukuda

2013

Japan

ICR mice

Unclear

60 min/2, 6 h

Unclear

AD, autologous, 1 × 105/106

i.p

Immediately

Gao

2010

China

Wistar rats/m

≈ 200 g

20 min/0.5, 1, 3, 7, 14, 28 d

Unclear

BM, allogeneic, 1 × 106

Caudal vein

Immediately

Geng

2016

China

SD rats/m

180–220 g

30 min/2 h

Unclear

BM, allogeneic, 1 × 107

Caudal vein

Immediately

Jensena

2016

USA

C57Bl6 mice/m

8–12 w, 20–30 g

60 min/12, 24 h

Isoflurane

hAD, 2 × 106

i.p

Unclear

Jensenb

2016

USA

C57Bl6 mice/m

8–12 w, 20–30 g

60 min/12, 24 h

Isoflurane

hAD, hUD, 2 × 106

i.p

Unclear

Jensen

2018

USA

C57Bl6 mice/m

8–12 w

60 min/24 h

Isoflurane

hUD, 2 × 106

i.p

Immediately

Jiang

2011

China

SD rats/f

180–200 g

45 min/4, 7 d

Ketamine

BM, allogeneic (m), 1 × 107

Local injection

Immediately

Jiang

2013

China

SD rats/f

180–220 g

45 min/1, 4, 7 d

Ketamine

BM, allogeneic (m), 1 × 107

Local injection

Immediately

Kong

2020

China

SD rats/m

250–300 g

30 min/72 h

Pentobarbital

AD, allogeneic, 2 × 106

Caudal vein

Unclear

Liu

2016

China

SD rats

6–8 w/180–210 g

30 min/2, 6, 24, 72, 120 h

Unclear

BM, allogeneic, 5 × 106

Local injection

Unclear

Liu

2020

China

C57Bl6 mice

20–25 g

60 min/2 d

Pentobarbital

AD, allogeneic, 5 × 106

Local injection

Unclear

Markel

2015

USA

C57Bl6 mice/m

8–12 w/20-30 g

60 min/6 h

Isoflurane

hBM, 2 × 104/105/106

i.p

Unclear

Oliveira

2018

Brazil

NZ rabbits

≈ 10 w/≈ 3 kg

2 h/3, 7 d

Xylazine, ketamine, tramadol, isoflurane

AD, allogeneic, 1.2 × 106

Marginal auricular vein

5 h

Shen

2013

China

SD rats/m

120–200 g

30 min/2, 6, 24, 72, 144 h

Chloral hydrate

BM, allogeneic, 1 × 107

Local injection

Immediately

Watkins

2013

USA

FVB mice/m

8–10 w/≈ 20 g

60 min/24 h

Isoflurane

BM/AF (from C57Bl6 mice), 1 × 106

i.p

2 h

Yan

2019

China

SD rats/m

unclear

60 min/1, 7 d

Pentobarbital

BM, allogeneic, 1 × 107

i.p

Unclear

  1. SD: Sprague–Dawley; f: female; m: male; MSCs: mesenchymal stem cells; BM: Bone marrow; hBM: Human BM; AD: adipose-derived; AF: amniotic fluid; hUD: Human umbilical Cord; NZ: New Zealand; i.p.: intraperitoneal; min: minute(s); h: hour(s); d: day(s); w: week(s); g: gram(s); kg: kilogram(s); USA: United States of America