Skip to main content

Table 2 BMD: stratified analysis of MSC-treated vs. control

From: Systemic therapy of MSCs in bone regeneration: a systematic review and meta-analysis

 

Subgroup

N

Effect estimate

I2

p*

p**

Species of animals

Mice

11

5.67 (3.78, 7.56)

94%

p<0.00001

p<0.0001

Rat

5

0.34 (− 1.08, 1.76)

88%

p<0.00002

 

Swine

Not calculated

  

Types of MSCs

BMSCs

12

3.23 (1.63, 4.84)

94%

p<0.00001

P=0.76

Other MSCs

5

2.86 (1.13, 4.60)

87%

p<0.00001

 

Frequency of injection

Single injection

14

2.20 (1.03, 3.37)

92%

p<0.00001

N

Multiple injection

Not calculated

Time of injection

Before modeling

Not calculated

N

At the same time of modeling

Not calculated

After modeling

14

3.92 (2.59, 5.52)

93%

p<0.00001

Bone diseases

Bone defect

12

2.26 (0.99, 3.54)

92%

p<0.00001

p=0.05

Systematic bone diseases

5

6.25 (2.45, 10.05)

92%

p<0.00001

 

Sex of animals

Male

6

3.64 (1.02, 6.27)

96%

p<0.00001

p=0.65

Female

5

2.88 (0.90, 4.86)

89%

p<0.00001

 
  1. p* value for heterogeneity within each subgroup. p** value for heterogeneity between subgroups with meta-regression analysis. MSCs, mesenchymal stem cells; BMSCs, bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells