Skip to main content

Table 2 Meta-analysis of clinical symptoms in pre- and post-therapy

From: The assessment of mesenchymal stem cells therapy in acute on chronic liver failure and chronic liver disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled clinical trials

Symptom

Time point

Number of studies

Heterogeneity

Odds ratio (OR)

95% CI

P value

I2

P value

Encephalopathy

Baseline

2

0

0.457

0.65

0.30–1.41

0.278

 

End of treatment

2

31.8

0.231

0.40

0.18–0.89

0.025

Gastrointestinal hemorrhage

Baseline

3

0

0.491

0.80

0.19–3.35

0.760

 

End of treatment

3

1.9

0.361

0.32

0.07–0.97

0.045

Edema

Baseline

4

0

0.379

1.33

0.58–3.06

0.495

 

End of treatment

4

46.6

0.132

0.64

0.27–1.49

0.298

Rash

Baseline

4

0

0.491

1.11

0.22–5.73

0.900

 

End of treatment

4

9.2

0.347

0.73

0.26–2.07

0.555

Itching

Baseline

2

0

0.491

0.44

0.06–3.16

0.417

 

End of treatment

2

57.2

0.127

0.45

0.08–2.45

0.352

  1. 95% CI, 95% confidence interval